After being released by WWE in April 2005, Molly Holly appeared sporadically on a few occasions in the company. In December 2007 she appeared backstage of the episode dedicated to the 15th anniversary of Raw together with Mickie James, William Regal and Hornswoggle.
She then made a brief comeback in 2009, taking part in the Miss WrestleMania Battle Royal held at WrestleMania XXV, alongside other former WWE wrestlers, such as Victoria, Torrie Wilson and Miss Jackie. Hers was the fourteenth name to be eliminated, caused by Beth Phoenix.
On January 27, 2016, she appeared at the WWE Network Program Table for 3 alongside wrestlers Alundra Blayze and Ivory. She reappeared on the show on May 18, this time alongside Candice Michelle and Michelle McCool. On January 28, 2018, at the Royal Rumble, Molly returned to the WWE ring by participating in the first Women's Royal Rumble in history, being eliminated by Michelle McCool.
Subsequently, on April 6, Molly inducted one of her former opponents, Ivory, into the WWE Hall of Fame. She returned to battle on October 28, 2018, at the Evolution pay-per-view by taking part in the 20-Women Battle Royal. On January 26, 2020, she took part in the Women's royal rumble match, this time as Mighty Molly, but was eliminated by Bianca Belair.
Molly Holly was on the latest episode of the Pro Wrestling 4 Life podcast hosted by WWE Hall of Famer Sean Waltman, aka X-PAC. During her appearance on the show, Molly Holly opened up about her romantic storyline with Spike Dudley and had nothing but praise for the former WWE Superstar.
Molly Holly opens up on Spike Dudley
"It was awesome," Said Molly Holly. "To even be involved in any kind of storyline is huge. It's still fun to be on Sunday Night Heat but to be thrown in a situation where you're just doing a four-minute match for no reason, it's like, I want to do so much more.
So when they put me in the storyline with Spike Dudley where we're like having this Disney romance, we like each other and it's all sweetness." Molly Holly continued: "I liked it and Spike was super nice, a good person to be paired up with.
You don't want to be paired up with some creeper that's going to take advantage of the situation, so he was very great to work with and it worked out awesome that the Dudleys were so popular. It kind of brought up my popularity just being in the skits with them."